Skip to content
Y
yTube.SITE v8.0.4
media / worlds / tools / internet oddities
YouTube / video information

Whales Came From a Tiny Deer

Video information, playback and saved actions.

Whales Came From a Tiny Deer

Description: The cat-sized, deer-like animal from ancient India that was family to the blue whale

Put the biggest animal known beside something the size of a house cat, with thin legs and little hooves. That is what whales' family looked like on land, in India about 48 million years ago. It is not the wolf-like Pakicetus that most whale-evolution videos show, because Pakicetus was already a whale. Researchers think this little plant-eater leapt into a stream when danger came and let its heavy leg bones hold it on the bottom until the danger had gone. A living African mousedeer hides underwater the same way, so the trick alone proves nothing. The real giveaway sat inside a skull, and nobody saw it until that skull broke while it was being cleaned.

0:00 The tiny deer and the blue whale
0:17 Danger at the stream
0:32 How we know

All Gone Animals Shorts: https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLfZ2odR62pH8

Sources and caveats
- Thewissen, Cooper, Clementz, Bajpai and Tiwari 2007, «Whales originated from aquatic artiodactyls in the Eocene epoch of India», Nature 450: 1190–1194: https://www.nature.com/articles/nature06343 (abstract: https://ideas.repec.org/a/nat/nature/v450y2007i7173d10.1038_nature06343.html)
- Ideastream, «In search of walking whales», 2014: https://ideastream.org/news/health-science/2014-08-04/in-search-of-walking-whales
- Wikipedia, Indohyus: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Indohyus
- Wikipedia, Pakicetidae, citing Nummela et al. 2007, Anatomical Record 290: 716–733: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pakicetidae
- Wikipedia, Blue whale: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Blue_whale
- ScienceDaily, December 2007: https://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2007/12/071220220241.htm
- National Geographic, «Whales evolved from small aquatic hoofed ancestors»: https://www.nationalgeographic.com/science/article/whales-evolved-from-small-aquatic-hoofed-ancestors
- National Geographic, «Science word of the day: involucrum», 2015: https://www.nationalgeographic.com/science/article/science-word-of-the-day-involucrum
- Discover: https://www.discovermagazine.com/whales-evolved-from-small-aquatic-hoofed-ancestors-334
- Philadelphia Inquirer, 20 December 2007: https://www.inquirer.com/philly/news/nation_world/20071220_Deer-like_ancestor_of_whales_suggested.html
- Cranial anatomy of Indohyus, Palaeo-Electronica 2024: https://palaeo-electronica.org/content/2024/5187-cranial-anatomy-of-indohyus
- Grzimek's Animal Life Encyclopedia, «Chevrotains (Tragulidae)»: https://www.encyclopedia.com/environment/encyclopedias-almanacs-transcripts-and-maps/chevrotains-tragulidae
- The animal is Indohyus, a raoellid. It was not a true deer, only built like a small one with no antlers. It is not a direct ancestor of whales either. The 2007 paper places it as the closest known relative of whales on land, just outside the whale group, and the narration's «came from a family» means that.
- Whales' closest living relatives are hippos, and some scientists said in 2007 that the raoellid idea needs more testing.
- «Cat-sized» is one of several sizes in the sources. Thewissen called it raccoon-sized, other reports say fox-sized or about 70 cm long, and no full size estimate has been published.
- «About 48 million years ago» is an approximate date. The rock layer is dated to roughly 48.7–45.4 million years ago, overlapping Pakicetus. The Short does not say which of the two is older.
- The dive is researchers' reading of the bones and teeth, not something anyone saw. Its leg bones have a thick outer layer, as in hippos, and its tooth chemistry matches animals that spent time in water. Walking along the bottom is Thewissen's picture of it. The shadow stands for an unknown predator, and how long it stayed under is not known.
- The mousedeer (0:28) is Africa's water chevrotain, of the mouse-deer family. Grzimek's: «When disturbed, it escapes by plunging into the water.» A comparison, not evidence about Indohyus.
- The ear bone (0:37) is the involucrum. National Geographic: «Living and fossil, whales are united by a thick wall of bone over their ears.» Wikipedia, Pakicetidae: «The tympanic bulla in pakicetid ears is similar to those in all cetaceans, with a relatively thin lateral wall and thickened medial part known as the involucrum.» The 2007 paper reported it in Indohyus. The curl in the drawing is the artist's choice.
- The fossils come from rock blocks that the Indian geologist A. Ranga Rao collected decades earlier in Kashmir, India. His widow later gave Thewissen access to them. Thewissen says a lab assistant broke part of a skull while cleaning it, and the broken part was the ear; Wikipedia says a student. The Short names nobody.
- Indohyus's colour, fur and face are reconstructions. Its skeleton was pieced together from hundreds of bones of several animals.
- Pictures: AI-generated flat drawings, animated in code. Voice and music: AI-generated (ElevenLabs). Close description
      
Videos related to "Whales Came From a Tiny Deer"